MLMs: The Legal Pyramid Scheme
You get a message from an acquaintance. They mention a “business opportunity.”
They’re vague about the details and insist “all your questions will be answered during the meeting.”
It’s the classic MLM (Multi-Level Marketing) pitch — using familiarity and social pressure to make a sale.
I’ve been approached many times over the years, and the playbook never changes. Knowing how to spot these scams early can save you time, money, and even friendships.
MLM vs. Pyramid Scheme
MLMs are often compared to pyramid schemes, and for good reason. Both rely on constant recruitment to keep money flowing. The only difference?
MLMs technically sell a product, which keeps them legal.
A normal business sells a product or service and pays employees for their work.
In contrast, MLMs make most of their money from recruiting new sellers, not from selling products to real customers.
In short:
- A shoe company makes money selling shoes.
- An MLM makes money selling dreams — usually to its own salespeople.
Why MLMs Love “Independent Contractors”
In an MLM, everyone is a sales rep — and a recruiter. There are no salaries, no benefits, and no liability for the company.
By labeling everyone as an independent contractor, the company avoids:
- Paying taxes or wages
- Following labor or safety laws
- Providing any real support
This setup is by design. It’s low risk for the company and high risk for you.
The Pyramid in Action
Everyone in an MLM can “hire” as many people as they want. There are no qualifications because there’s no cost to the company — only potential upside.
Each sale you make gives a cut to the person above you, and every person you recruit sends a cut of their sales to you. It’s a pyramid-shaped incentive structure disguised as “team building.”
That’s where the pitch for “passive income” comes in: make money off the people you recruit.
But as you’ll see below, that’s mostly a fantasy.
How MLMs Mirror Ponzi Schemes
MLMs and pyramid schemes both trace their roots to Ponzi schemes — named after Charles Ponzi.
He promised investors profits from legitimate business activity but simply paid old investors using money from new ones.
That’s where the phrase “robbing Peter to pay Paul” comes from.
Both structures collapse when recruitment slows — because there’s no real money being made from customers.
The Reality: Who Actually Profits
Yes, real money can be made in MLMs — but it’s mostly by the founders and early entrants.
According to ChatGPT’s data summary:
Over 99% of participants lose money after expenses (inventory, travel, training, events, etc.).
A 2018 AARP Foundation study found:
- 47% of MLM participants lost money
- 27% broke even
- Only 25% made any profit (mostly small)
Your odds of turning a profit are roughly 1 in 100.
So when you get a vague pitch for a “business opportunity” — that’s your red flag waving.
How They Recruit You (and Everyone You Know)
MLMs rely heavily on your personal network. The average person has around 100–250 acquaintances, and most recruits burn through that list fast — friends, family, coworkers, classmates — before moving on to “friends of friends.”
Here’s a real example:
A friend of mine (we’ll call him Bob) “interviewed” for a position with World Financial Group, a financial-services MLM.
During the interview, Bob listed me as a reference. While verifying his employment history, the recruiter immediately tried to schedule a meeting with me to pitch their services disguised as training for Bob.
Before Bob even joined, they were already leveraging his social circle. It’s a clever strategy — and disturbingly effective.
Classic MLM Pitches
If you hear any of these lines, proceed with caution:
- “This is your chance to own your own business.”
- “Be your own boss — no more 9-to-5 grind!”
- “Start a business for less than a coffee a day.”
- “You’re not selling — you’re sharing a product you love.”
- “We’re not an MLM — we’re a direct sales company.”
- “It’s not a job, it’s a lifestyle opportunity.”
- “If you put in the work, you can make unlimited income.”
If someone has to convince you their company isn’t a pyramid scheme… it probably is.
Real companies (like Google or Nike) don’t need to say that.
Red Flags in MLM Messages
They won’t say the company name
They want to control the narrative. A quick Google search would expose them.
They’re vague about what the job is
They describe a lifestyle, not tasks or responsibilities.
They focus on “opportunity,” not product
Recruiting matters more than sales.
They emphasize “mentorship” or “community”
That’s code for recruiting new members.
They offer a “quick chat” or Zoom call
They rely on emotion and social pressure — not facts.
They’re vague about pay or say it’s “unlimited”
Legit jobs have clear pay structures.
They name-drop legitimate brands
They borrow credibility to sound legitimate.
The Real Estate Comparison
I recently had a recruiter reach out and compare his company to a real estate company trying to get credibility from that legitimate industry. First of all real estate company are a mess unto themselves with their death like stranglehold on the buying and selling of house with intense lobbying to keep the monopoly to themselves which is extremely problematic and anti capitalist.
But putting that to the side Real estate firms also want to hire as many realtors as physically possible having very little standards on who they take since every realtor signed up has to pay monthly brokerage fees to be a member as well as commission split on every sale, almost exactly like an MLM. The similarity is uncanny.
Now I am not saying real estate agents are in an MLM, as there are some differences, for example not everyone can recruit to create a downline, only brokerages can. The structure although different is eerily similar.
Knowledge Is Power
When you’re young and just starting out, no one warns you about these traps.
Schools don’t teach this stuff, and sometimes friends unknowingly rope you in.
The best defense? Awareness.
If you can recognize the signs early, you’ll save yourself a lot of wasted time and money.
Below is a list of common MLMs to watch out for. If you ever get pitched one of these names — that’s your cue to walk away.
List of MLM Companies
Skincare & Beauty
Mary Kay – Cosmetics
Nu Skin – Anti-aging skincare, supplements
Isagenix – Weight loss and nutrition
Opulence Global – Fashion, skincare, wellness
Avon – Skincare and cosmetics
Arbonne – Nutrition and beauty
Supplements & Food
Herbalife – Supplements and meal replacements
PM-International – FitLine nutrition
Atomy – Health and beauty
Immunotec – Supplements
Epicure – Food and cookware
Financial MLMs
World Financial Group – Insurance and investments
Primerica – Financial services
Experior Financial Group – Investments and insurance
World System Builder – Financial education
Household Products
Cutco – Kitchen knives
Amway – Supplements, skincare, energy drinks
Norwex – Cleaning products
Tupperware – Household storage
Sources and Research
If a “friend” or “recruiter” reaches out with a mysterious business opportunity — do your homework before saying yes. While money can be made it is extremely rare and efforts would be much better spent getting a real job.
Google the company name + “MLM.”
Or better yet, ask ChatGPT or a trusted advisor about it first.
The more you know, the harder it is for them to sell you the dream.
.jpeg)
.jpeg)
No comments:
Post a Comment